Coop's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[Adolf Hitler:CAI493+D 093]

Very Simple

Same background picture as yesterday, an easy change of image from Gastly yesterday to Haunter. You've managed to delete Hitler's aura, which looked pretty shite yesterday, so that's a bonus.

At least we've got some animation today, in the Gastly - Haunter evolution gif. While it might be a simple animation, it has at least sorted the criterea of one of my demands in yesterday's review.

Therefore, todays demand is the following: Put Bahamut's Afro_Stud character in your next flash!

[Review Request Club]

AfroUnderscoreStud responds:

It would have been there even if you hadn't asked for it. It's something that's been present since #2.

I was going to put AfroStar in #094 as an Easter egg just for you, but unfortunately I didn't have any free time. :(

[Jim: The Movie (Trailer)]

*Calls advance previews hotline*

Well, this is certainly a very good trailer for an eagerly anticipated movie. I think that you could have done with having the option of subtitles - trying to hear what everyone is saying is difficult, when trying to watch the animation and trying to keep the volume down from watching it at work :P

Still, the graphics are awesome (Loved the way you portrayed Jim as simple, showing his component shapes and then his reaction to your 'badly drawn' comment.) And so is the plotline. Obviously, I'd like to see the rest of the movie, as you've given us the highlights and the coming never is bound to be bullshit... isn't it?

You're a great animator and it is time for you to take the next big step of putting a full feature together, dammit!

[Review Request Club]

Jimtopia responds:

Almost everyone who's reviewed wants me to make this into a full length cartoon, but honestly that's just not in the cards at the moment. I really want to finish my submission for the X-mas 07 contest, that's my main priority right now. I guess we'll have to see what 2008 brings in the way of Jim, but I gotta say, a big movie wouldn't be for a long time, if ever. Plus if I did make this into a "full feature" I would have to include all these parts into it, and I think that could really screw up the storyline, lol. Anyway, I appreciate the vote of confidence that you usually give me in your reviews, but Jim isn't meant for a long cartoon, at least not yet. Maybe someday you'll get tickets to go see the full length "Jim: The Movie" in theaters; wouldn't that be cool? =P

[Adolf Hitler:CAI493+D 088]

What, no evolution?

Didn't some of the previous flash in this series start by having a pokemon (previous episode's character?) evolve into the new beastie which is the feature of the episode.

Obviously, I'd like to see better animation, as Hitler should at least make a small attempt to dance. How else is he supposed to steal Tutenkhamun's thunder as most famous dead person. I know he'd never end up hosting Strictly Come Dancing, but I'm sure there could be other career opportunities for straight armed pointing, like a weatherman, or something.

[Review Request Club]

AfroUnderscoreStud responds:

Yep, but Grimer is the first form :P

[mosquito kill]

Harsh

Well, that was an amazingly brutal piece. I wasn't expecting that at all.

Leonardo looks really freaky with his completely solid white eyes. The way that the facial expression shows off his murderous intent was really good though.

Although the flash was too short, there is a simple way that you could have made it longer - make a short freeze frame, similar to in the Road Runner cartoons, showing each character with their name and maybe something witty about them as well. Also, don't have the characters of their names jumping up and down, as they become quite difficult to read.

Maybe also do one for the Mosquito, as that would be a chance to show off drawing skills of something other than a person or background. A title for the mosquito like 'The Aggravotor' would help, for example.

[Review Request Club]

peixeaquatico responds:

yes thanks really I have what improve

XD

[iShirm&Rena #2 HS]

Worth a look

I've watched both parts and will deliver verdicts on both below:

iShirm - I didn't understand the language of the pumpkin song, but I would definately have preferred the pumpkin to remain the same size, with the mouth changing size - stretching it just didn't seem to work. Samuel L. Jackson was a bit of a shock, as he bludgeoned the skit to death.

Little-Rena - I thought the Pumpkin was cute. Though it could have done with a mouth (and maybe a bow on its head :P) I'm not sure about the way it died, in the shower of colour, but that's the only real gripe I have.

Maybe grab a few more buddies and make some extra parts, to improve the longevity of the piece, but other than that, you're on the right track.

[Review Request Club]

iShirm responds:

Oh man that was long :P thanks for this great review, make sure you'll see the third part it'll surely be better :D