Coop's audio Reviews on Newgrounds

[[Brawl 8-Bit] Green Greens]

Light and fast

I'm not sure about the start of the tune, but other than that, it's a fast paced, slightly higher pitched than needed, but otherwise a good sounding piece.

I think it's another piece that could use extrapolation and may run afoul of copyright rules, but if that's alright then you're onto a winner.

[Review Request Club]

loogiesquared responds:

T_o?

[mac8 - dawn after the fight]

Too much static

There's a good sense of foreboding around this track and it would be nice to take this further, but the main problem that I have encountered with this is the large amounts of static that resonate around the bells and some of the higher pitched notes.

It's got a good chance to be great, but I would also suggest that the pauses are reduced, with something else in the early running of the track, just to keep the momentum going

[Review Request Club]

[vortex^2]

Not bad

Not particularly good either, but it's a basis to work on - with a little more work, you could turn this into a decent sounding piece - give us some more length, as the variation starts to kick in and then the loop starts again.

I think that with the way that you started (slow and steady), you've built a nice base to build on with a thumping bass beat and then some keyboards, just to take the song out of the intro and into the next phase of the song.

[Review Request Club]

[into the darkness.]

Mortal Kombat!

Sounds very MK in the background - the only thing that was missing was the guy yelling "Mortal Kombat!" I think that it is a nice sounding piece - great buildup, so it has great probability as a menu piece.

With looking to make it better, I'd suggest looking to make it longer (maybe 2 minutes) and work on making this loop something that could be used in a fight - it's more of an intro to that, which is a good start, but only a start at the moment.

[Review Request Club]

[All Night Party 11]

Quite balanced

A nice sounding track that has quite a few nice blends of features, combined with a driving, but not possessive beat. It's a refreshing song that doesn't quite make me want to get up and dance about it, but I think that it can certainly go places.

It doesn't quite loop right, but over time I think that this can be worked on - try making it slightly longer, which would distract from that feature, especially if it's down to my laggy connection, or something, which is a possibility, I suppose. Personally, I think you're about a half to a third of a beat away from a perfect loop, but it might be something slightly different.

[Review Request Club]

[Depth of Thought]

Nice sound

A good driving bass beat is certainly what pushes this tune to new levels. A nice melody and a good balance between the two components really add a good flavour to the track. A pleasant bonus was the fact that it loops well as well.

The composition was good and the counter melody that came into the track in the middle was a nice boost, although more variation could certainly only be a boon for this track.

Good work, keep it up.

[Review Request Club]

TheBellmaker responds:

I do agree that this track needs more variation, although I partly consider a test for my new z3ta plugin. The next song that I wrote is a better composition as a whole. Thanks for the review!

[JuMP3r - Bounce!]

Pounding

A great start! Welcome to submitting on Newgrounds.

A track that is based heavily around the beat and the synths - I would leave out some of the pauses, just to help with the continuity of the track - it would work better if you had some sort of solo, either the synth or the bass just carrying on a little longer, before catching with the pick up of the backing melody again.

This track could well have a great many uses for games on Newgrounds and even some movies, but that's quite ambiguous - the games could be for any menu, but I think that skill games would be the best choice for this

[Review Request Club]