Coop's audio Reviews on Newgrounds

[Whales [Box-Killa]]

An interesting tune

Perhaps the sounds of the bass track were a little low for that of Whales. I'm not entirely convinced by the way the track went together.

I think that you've got a good melody sound and when the short, sharp notes are added to it, you get a good sound. The bass is a little overpowering and when it gets to the situation that there's a little too much bass there, so it tends to top out with static, it's a shame.

With whale sounds, they tend to be quite long and graceful notes - the ones that you've used seem to be short and punctuated, but it doesn't really detract from the tranquility of the piece, the bass does that :P

[Review Request Club]

Box-Killa responds:

fanks coopy :D

[Come on lets Go!]

Great loop

A nice little loop, showing that you've got a good taste for versatility and rock guitar. I'm not quite sure if you've hit another drum every time you've hit a cymbal, but it certainly would help if this was the case - the balance sounds slightly off, so perhaps calm the sound of the cymbals down slightly and turn up the sounds for the drums when they are struck themselves.

A little short for my liking, as it's not really a proper loop, but with a little more variation and experimentation, you'll be able to produce a great sounding piece.

[Review Request Club]

sicjes responds:

Thanks for the great feedback. I play guitar and did all the tracks as for everything else... well its all fake, the drums were done on my Yamaha rx11 prehistoric drum machine (I finally got fruity loops a few weeks back) and I did the bass with my keyboard. I have some new tunes I'm working on and they will blow you away both in sound quality and Catchyness. Stay tuned for some crazy awsomness coming from my way. Thanks again bro.

[itookachillpill]

Chilled accoustics

I think that what you really need to lose is the sound of you sniffing just before you start playing :P

But in all seriousness, you are a pretty talented musician. Perhaps the use of a metronome would help you with the timing, as the pace of the track just seems to be something that you move about with a little too much.

I'd consider moving this forward by adding lyrics, as the track on its own is brilliant, but if you added lyrics, it would be awesome.

[Review Request Club]

loansindi responds:

But i like the sniff!

A lot of the tempo's fluidity is intentional, I don't think solo guitar pieces can work with a rigid tempo, they get boring. That said, I'm sure the range could be tighter.

Lyrics are definitely planned. Thanks for the review.

[[LY] Afternoon Blazing [D]]

Tranquil

An interesting track that seems a little repetitive, when it comes to the beat, but it's still soothing and it calms the mind, while allowing for the expression to continue forward, giving a deep sense of relief and bliss.

If you could come up with another bass riff or two, just to break the monotony of this track it would be much appreciated. At 2. 25, it's a good length, improved by the presence of a loop, so you're doing well already. Taking it to that next step is always a plus and I'd hope to see you doing that in the near future.

[Review Request Club]

la-yinn responds:

Aye, it is a bit repetitive right now, but it is only the fundament of the whole track. I doubt I'll be changing the bass riffs, but there will be more instruments and melodies to keep the listener entertained.

The 'next step' is coming up this week. Full version will be a bit longer, it'll loop with some more flow and it'll have more variation.

Thanks for the review! :-)

[Final Days]

Good pace - not so sure about quality

This seems to be one of the pieces where quantity takes precedence over quality. It's a shame, but if you're going to release something like this, perhaps give it a new edit and really show people what you're capable of in the here and now.

I don't think that this is particularly bad, as the pace of the tune is great, combined with the way that everything works together so nicely, but the backing guitar or keyboards (I couldn't tell, sorry) works so nicely, that I feel it deserves its own solo in the song and perhaps some lyrics would be the next step.

[Review Request Club]

[mik // the beach \\]

Very interresting

Perhaps a few other sounds of the beach could be incorporated - bird song, for example? I think that you're certainly on the right track with this happy little loop, which was a really nice touch, by the way.

If you take it further, you'll certainly be able to make it better - some of the louder 'bass crashes' as the larger waves break the surf in the deeper waters. If you take that sort of thing into consideration, you'll be onto a winner here.

[Review Request Club]

[Ominous Theme]

A little creepy

I think that the way it starts is brilliant. The strangled bagpipes that you've got to make a creepy noise in the background is actually quite chilling. With the way that the pieces fall into place here, I was surprised that it didn't carry on for longer.

I was very disappointed with the ending - it sounded like you could keep it going for maybe another minute longer, but then it decided to end with a brick wall stop. Given that it was so promising, I've scored it so high, but please don't leave it like that - go for the jugular!

[Review Request Club]

Centrist responds:

Alright, I'll fix this monkey up since so many of you want to see it done. ;D

[ECHO - Sons of Scotland (]

Nae bad

Well, I think that a Scottish theme marching tune would have more of a snare to it - this is a drum kit snare, as opposed to the sharp, crisp sound that you get with a marching band. Have a look on YouTube for Trooping the Colour and you'll hear exactly what I mean.

Still, the sound in the background hardly reflects bagpipes either - I think that you're making close approximations there, but it's not quite what people are after in a proper Scottish tune. Given that you've taken main inspiration from the computer game Worms, it's got a ways to come just yet :P I can hear the first few bars "We are worms, we're the best and we've come to win the war", but then it does change. Perhaps change it before then, so that it is only inspired, rather than copied - you'll get far much more credit.

[Review Request Club]

[No Savior v.3]

Quite morbid

Well, that tune is quite a requiem for someone about to die - it's very powerful and it carries with it a deep sense of regret and longing for salvation. I think that the main power source of this tune is from the strings, but the hard hitting power of the drum beat really does cap it off for me.

I can see where you're coming from with the additional kick from the headphones, but what you might need here to make it sound the most epic that you can is an Organ in the background. This is the most grandiose of all instruments and the power that you would hold would be capable of stripping flesh from bone!

[Review Request Club]

Centrist responds:

Baha, what a review. I see where you're coming from, and I will take that into strong consideration! That would work perfectly for what I was trying to go for, and it would add much more depth, wouldn't it?

Thanks mate!

[Nephelheim]

Interesting introduction

Well, it's certainly a very good tune, but the introduction just feels so out of place, I couldn't even see them as being the same tune. It certainly fits the industrial genre and you've worked a very nice beat and melody into a powerful, robust little tune here.

I think that the melody could give way to the counter-melody slightly in places, or perhaps it's just an indication that you need to calm the counter melody down a little. I'm sure that sitting and puzzling through it will help with this, but I can't personally put my finger on which of the two variables needs changing.

[Review Request Club]

Centrist responds:

Well, before I got to NG, I used to make songs like every day. I uploaded the best I had, and I forgot to edit them before said upload. The problem I have is when I start a song, I do no pre-planning. I start off with dabbling around and doing something that I think sounds funky or cool, then I just build and build. Everything you hear from me I come up with right on the spot as I make it. Whether or not that's a good thing, I'll never know, but I generally just run with what I have. :]

Thanks for the review!