Coop's audio Reviews on Newgrounds

[[herd] Uprising Trek]

Loops well

Not that looping a track makes for a good piece, but in this case, it doesn't really make that much of a difference.

I think that with the way that you break the track up with the interludes of the higher pitched synths. The problem is that the track seems a little repetitive, which is where the looping for me fails. What I would suggest is more variation, in additional instruments or bigger differences in the parts of the tune that you concentrate on. Verse, Chorus, Verse etc.

[Review Request Club]

Herdunculus responds:

Yes thanks. I have been getting a lot of the "more variation" advice. I will try to do exactly that on my next songs. Oh, and I didn't realize it is a good loop. I didn't try to do that! LOL. Thanks for the review.

[musicmachine - cover]

Not bad

I think this is a nice piece - I'm not in the mood for listening to the piece that this is a cover of. With how it sounds, I'm sure that I don't have to. I like the guitar that this piece has acting as a backing tune, but you bring it out nicely. It could do with a full-blown solo, but other than that, it's got a very nice feel to it.

There are some good vocals here - I'm not sure if you've just sampled them from the original, but if you have, it's a very good job with editing them into the rest of the tune, so good stuff.

[Review Request Club]

loansindi responds:

I'm glad you enjoyed it. The original piece is a high-energy electro-pop piece that's a bit of fun.

I was pretty happy with the way the instrumentals turned out. Like I stated in the description the vocals are from the original band. They were released in a pack for a remix contest, and I obtained their permission to upload my submission here.

[SN | No Purpose Flour | SN]

Nice sound

This piece has a very good pace and rhythm to it, with a nice listener dynamic, where you can keep it as a very easy piece of Drum & Bass to listen to. I particularly like the melody that you've constructed here. Perhaps it could have used a little more on the bass line, but that's down to your own feelings, as the artist ;)

With the way that it pans out, you've got a good dynamic, especially when it seems like a spinning coin coming to a stop. It's a nice way to picture the image that goes along with the piece, so as it develops, there is this wonderful image of a spaceship flying along and this spinning sound seems to be something like a drive engine, or something that we keep cutting back to this force that seems to be driving everything. At the end, I can just picture it coming to a standstill and the lights fading around the engine, as the song fades out.

[Review Request Club]

SessileNomad responds:

i love the spinning coin image, idk why that struck me, but it did, i like the lights fading as well

im glad you liked it enough lol

more bass, i always get told to do that xD

[Watch It Burn (WIP)]

Very Oasis

A nicely written tune that really does have an easy listening quality to it. I think that you could do with taking that first few seconds of silence off the track, because no-one wants to think that their player might be broken, but that's only a minor niggle as things go.

The modulation was a little outlandish, so it could have been handled a little better, since the transition was quite rough and sudden, so perhaps making it a little smoother would have been the answer to this issue. I'm still thinking that the whole song is a good sounding piece, even though it's not really my type of music, so keep at it and I'll be interested to hear more of this stuff.

[Review Request Club]

[Devotion do_ob]

Interesting tempo

Hmm, this track has certainly got some strange dynamics to it. The way that the tempo builds up and gets the whole track moving from mild and ambient to fast and active is strange, but I love the way that you finish it like a loop.

It's serene and pleasant to the ears, then when the speed changes, the backing still retains that serene quality and it gives a nice change to the piece as a whole. I think that it could have done with a little more of a change, perhaps with a different instrument and just change the dynamic more completely.

[Review Request Club]

eatmeatleet responds:

Yea I guess I should have worked more since I couldn't come up with good changes

[Void (Mist Covered Realm)]

Sounds like a forest

I like this piece - it sounds tranquil, yet slightly mournful, as if something large from within has been taken away, which is a shame (Thus the Void, I guess). With how it all pans out, it possibly could have had a piano solo, sort of in a requiem, if that was what you were gunning for, with the loss. Perhaps the addition of a lone violin, just to exacerbate the feelings of grief as well.

For a void, the flute just didn't sound right - it sounds too light and airy, so I'd have suggested something that sounded a little lower key and perhaps more reserved.

Good length, good pace and I can certainly feel the mist curling around my arms as I walk through this once beautiful place.

[Review Request Club]

[Melody of the Wind]

Calming and spacey

I like the way that this sounds with the impression it gives of travelling without moving. There is possibly a little indication of some sort of forest or jungle themes creeping in here, but you need to work on the 'punctuation note', where it seems as if there is a little too loud of a sound, as it gives ever so slight amounts of static feedback at the top of the note.

There is certainly a very nice and calm presence in this track, that is carried by the beat consisting of the high-hat cymbals, which is a really nice sound, coupled with the drums that aren't overdone, which would be very easy to do.

Certainly worth perhaps adding some sort of a solo with the drums, but other than that, it's a very nice piece.

[Review Request Club]

[Peaceful_Adventure [Box-K]

Not bad

I think that you could do with speeding the tempo up a little on this, or at least evening it out. Perhaps a metronome will assist you here, just to be able to keep the beat going, where you might just be falling off the pace or going too fast for it in places.

It's a nice little tune, possibly akin to something that someone might play on their front porch during a summer's rain shower. Sad, but somehow slightly upbeat.

[Review Request Club]

[Golden Mind]

Intro / Outro put me off

Not a bad tune. Nice work with the instruments and the pace was well balanced with the vocals, which were well sung and the lyrics themselves were well written. What let the piece down was the length of the intro and outro, because these strange noises seemed not to have anything to do with the track and they took up over a minute of time on the track, which for me seemed excessive.

I think that trimming this to maybe 10 seconds would be ample and you would still be able to show the desired effect with the music. With the way that everything has panned out on this track, there is certainly many more positives to take out than negatives, so i look forward to your next work. I'd suggest some drums where it's just the claps, as the clapping for the percussion just doesn't seem to be strong enough. I know you're taking a softly softly approach, but losting the drums might be overkill.

[Review Request Club]

StickyRemnant responds:

I think I will trim the noise parts down. I'll see about trying to make the percussion stand out more. I was planning on eq'ing the claps (and its reverb) some to make them seem abit thicker. I may overlay another clap track over the existing one aswell.

Cheers for the review

[2010Rollers]

Reasonably peaceful

Not really what i was expecting from Drum & Bass, to be honest. I think that there's quite a well laid out piece, with some pleasing sounds to the drums, but too little in the bass department to make it a pure-bred drum & bass tune. I think that this might class as something like either dance or even just as Ambient.

The way that the intro and outro go is a little tranquil - I could certainly see you doing more for the outro, since it's just the one note, really. Taking that a little further and possibly adding something from this soft piano into the middle would certainly help your endeavours, I feel.

[Review Request Club]

eatmeatleet responds:

tnx