Coop's audio Reviews on Newgrounds

[Insecure]

Quite varied

Not really my cup of tea, but here goes:

I think that this mixed bag of bits and pieces needs to be extrapolated into the constituent tunes - it would appear that there are several styles and individual pieces mixed in here, which clash horribly, thus making the overall effect displeasing.

However, I am going to look further that that, as the beat and the starting melody are nice enough pieces, which get obsured almost immediately by the synth guitar, then by some sort of scat-based bass piano. refining of this piece could give at least three quality songs, which I would certainly look forward to hearing.

[Review Request Club]

ShortMonkey responds:

Thanks

[TransAmbience]

Tranquil

An interesting crossover of styles, with the way that this piece tends to gravitate more toward the ambient, then suddenly launches into this dance track, which is quite a contrast, although much has been worked on here in a definite concerted effort to blend the styles and make the transition as smooth and subtle as possible. I like the way it turned out, but I'm still not entirely sure of how it goes when the trance cuts in and the ambience is completely removed.

Personally, I would have kept the ambience running in the background, just to keep that part of the track going - when the trance cuts in completely, it takes over, which shouldn't be the case.

[Review Request Club]

jxl180 responds:

Ive gotten this suggestion a lot. I try it.

jxl180

[Paper Mario - Tutankoopa]

Old Skool Tribute

This tune certainly conjures up imagery of Mario from his earliest incarnations, during the first golden age of Nintendo gaming. Though it does have a taste of the Orient / Egypt about it, which I think works really well. I think that the Chinese oriental sounding bits and pieces complimented the Egyptian theme, which would be suggested by the title of this piece.

Though the ending fades out over about 10 seconds too much, it does calm down nicely towards the end, but if it were to be used in a game, it would be the major stumbling block for the author of that game.

[Review Request Club]

ninjakoopa-33 responds:

I'm glad you liked the Oriental / Egyptian sound. I'm actually surprised that it worked lol!
I understand that the ending kinda fades out too much, and would be a problem if it was used in a game.
Anyways, thanks for the review!

[HungHimselfWithAGuitarString]

Quite Dark

Mind you, what are we really to expect with a name like "Hung Himself With A Guitar String"?

So this tune encompasses all aspects of pain, fear, foreboding about one's impending doom and possibly regret as well. The feelings of what might have been must play upon the minds of those about to commit such an act of senseless ending.

I think that these emotions have been well documented and transmitted to the music, with a slow and painful death being more appropriate than a quick snap of the neck here. Since using a guitar string would tend to be more suicide than a professional execution, it wouldn't tend to engender the sudden end of a snapped neck, although I feel the track could benefit from a sudden ending, nonetheless.

[Review Request Club]

SymbolCymbal responds:

thanks for the awesome review but can i ask you a question?
can i buy some acid from you .. lol j/k
i really do appreciatte the visual aspect that you put twords the song..... i wrote it along time ago and decided to record it when i had an audio interface to mess with.
but in al seriousness i was just listening to beck when i named the song.. the darkness o fthat one line "He hung himself with a guitar string" just kinda stuc in my mind.
again thank you for the awesome review

[Solus- Cast Off]

Very Final Fantasy

This just reminds me of a general startup tune for the introduction of a Final Fantasy Saga, which builds up the expectations of a wonderful story that will take up the next 6-8 weeks of your free time in order to complete it.

I think that you've surpassed most piano on this site with this layout. It's a wonderful piece that conjures up such amazing imagery, but I would have to ask if it is hand played or whether you did it via a programme?

You've taken this piece to such incredible highs and lows on what has proven to be quite an emotional ride and though it sounds like one piece, it has proven to have much more depth and even a few chapters to in, none too dissimilar from an overture from soundtracks of all the great film scores.

[Review Request Club]

SolusLunes responds:

I wish I could say it was hand played- but alas, I cannot play the piano, so I had to use Reason to write this in. Well, rather, it kind of was hand played, as each note was played through a midi keyboard, just that it wouldn't sound anything like the song if you heard me play it. I really more entered this song in five-note or so increments, continuing as I felt I got it right. :D

[Solus- Forever Never]

Sounds more like classical to me

A nice piece, with the piano playing second fiddle to the percussion and brass, which is weird - the piano should and does tend to be one of the dominant pieces of an orchestra.

I'm interested in how you got inspired for this piece - the way that it sounds is that there is some sort of force sallying out slowly from a stronghold towards a battle. It doesn't sound like they got there, but it does seem that they marched out solemnly toward whatever fate they could carve for themselves.

To alter the piece, I'd make the piano the central part, which to me seems like a no-brainer, because pieces like this tend to get carried by such a powerful and expressive instrument.

[Reivew Request Club]

SolusLunes responds:

Ehhhhhhhhhhhh.

I DO like the piano, and I agree it does an epic job of carrying many music pieces, but I wanted to try something new for a lot of this.

The inspiration: First I started with the steel-string guitar part. Then it built from there- I guess it was just a result of tooling around in Reason.

[[AF] Godfather of Hardstyle]

Hard indeed

Certainly a hard, pumping beat, that has beaten the soft, grey matter between my ears into submission.

I think that you could have done with a few more bits and pieces of the tune, when you didn't have the driving beat, as aside from the driving beat, you had some other good tools to drive the tune along. An awesome cracking beat and the melody that came through at about the 2 minute marker. Sadly, when other parts of the tune increased in volume, you couldn't hear it, which was a real shame.

If you focused on these more subtle parts, I think this song would be brought a lot further forward. At least it's something to work on for the next version.

[Review Request Club]

agnryfaic responds:

Yeah, a couple of more hours of finetuning would've worked like a charm. Sadly, I'm a lazy bastard, so I didn't D:

Thanks for the rev ;)

[Toxic Biohazard V2]

Nah...

I'm not such a fan of this piece, as I was of the first one. You've made this shorter, less committed with regards to length and although you've made an attempt to loop it, you need to spend more time making sure that it sounds just right.

The concept of a biohazard is seemingly wandering lost in this tune, which is a shame. I can't really relate to anything to do with a biohazard for this one, so maybe I'm missing something along the way.

[Review Request Club]

loogiesquared responds:

._.

[puzzelish]

Too short

It's not a brilliant loop, but it does have potential. What I'd suggest is that you work on making the spaces between the notes equal, as there is one in the middle that is off by maybe a quarter of a second, but it makes such a difference, especially if it's on a track that loops over seven seconds.

When you get that sorted, loop it over and over for about 2-3 minutes, then expand upon it. Use this as the base and build up things like a beat, a melody and other bits and pieces to make the tune sound better. Sure, if you'regoing for an 8-Bit sounding loop, you don't have much to work with, but there is a lot more than you've got at present :)

[Review Request Club]

mikkim responds:

I'd seriously like to see you expand on this song.

[It`s a Dream( Deejay DeeZ RMX)]

Reach for the sun!

A wonderful piece, great vocal sampling, a lovely beat and a nice melody that has all been blended together perfectly. The only thing about this tune is that it doesn't loop. Still, that's just being a little picky.

What you need to do to make it better is to maybe have a 30s solo on the keyboards, possibly with the beat dropping in and out of the context, just to highlight that piece. You've done a little bridge of it, which was great, but I just feel that needs to be taken further.

[Review Request Club]

DeejayDeeZ responds:

Thanks, im glad you liked it :)

And yeah a keyboardbreak is a good idea, im not going to change this song, but I will remember it to next time.^^

- Deejay DeeZ